I need to state before getting into this review that I was given this book through BookSirens. Now that has been stated, I can now get into the book review. There are going to be spoilers in this review. This is an ARC copy. Please keep in mind that this book isn’t out yet and the author can change anything in the story.
From the very beginning, I felt completely pulled into Caramel-by-the-Sea. There was something so comforting about the witchy coastal setting that made me feel like I was right there, experiencing everything alongside Ally. I connected with her almost immediately. Her grief, the way she’s just been existing instead of really living, and how hard it is for her to move forward. It all felt very real to me and Jackie did an amazing job showcasing it.
Watching her slowly start to open back up, to her friends, to the magic around her, and to the possibility of love again. It was honestly really heartwarming and showed that you can live again. The little mysteries, especially the gifts showing up in her shop, kept me curious and turning pages, but what I loved most was the feeling of found family and support around her. And I can’t go on with this review if I don’t mention Toil and Trouble. They completely stole my heart and ran away with it.
That said, I did find myself wanting just a little more. I wanted to feel even deeper connections with the characters and spend more time on their emotional growth. The romance, while sweet and fitting for Ally’s journey, felt a bit light on the page for me, and I would’ve loved more of those moments.
Even with that, I still genuinely enjoyed my time with this book. It didn’t completely stick with me after I finished, but while I was reading, I was smiling, invested, and just at home in the story. And sometimes that’s exactly what I’m looking for in a book.
Favorite quote: “You were everything I’d imagined and more.” Which honestly sums up how I wanted to feel about this book.
If I’m being honest, this is exactly the kind of book that feels like a warm hug when I need one. Overall, this was a cozy, magical escape that I’m really glad I picked up, and I’m definitely interested in seeing where the series goes next.
Now for the star ratings I’m giving this book.
I’m giving this book an overall rating of 5 out of 5 stars.
The story is getting a rating of 5 out of 5 stars.
The writing style is getting a rating of 4 out of 5 stars.
The spicy level is getting a rating of 4 out of 5 stars.
The spicy rating would be a 2 according to romance.io stem rating guide. I’m taking a guess on what the rating would be as this book is not out yet.
Links
Amazon (Publish Date April 16, 2026)
Goodreads (Publish Date April 16, 2026)