I need to state before getting into this review that I was given this book through BookSirens. Now that has been stated, I can now get into the book review. There are going to be spoilers in this review. This is an ARC copy.
I felt like Into the Witch’s Garden was one of those books that’s just really easy to fall into. It follows Rhiannon, a self-taught green witch who moves to the city hoping to find others like her and hopefully get some answers about her missing aunt. I thought the premise was really interesting, especially once Leon shows up with a literal death curse tied to him and pulls her into something much bigger than she expected.
What I enjoyed the most was the overall vibe. I felt like the book had a soft, cozy, almost fairytale-like atmosphere with all the flowers, quiet magic, and gentle pacing. It’s the kind of story I’d reach for when I want something comforting and low-stress.
I thought the pacing worked well for how short it is, but I did feel like that meant some things weren’t explored as much as I wanted. I found myself wishing for a bit more depth when it came to the world and the magic, because it all felt a little surface-level at times.
I really liked how the romance was handled. I felt like it stayed in the background just enough and didn’t take over the story, which I appreciated since I was more interested in the mystery behind the curse. The balance between the two worked well for me.
That said, I didn’t fully connect with the characters. I felt like Rhiannon could be frustrating at times, and I didn’t always understand her decisions. I also really wish there had been more from Leon’s point of view. I felt as if he felt a bit distant, and I think getting inside his head more would have made a big difference.
I also thought the ending wrapped up a little too quickly, and some moments felt more told than shown. It’s definitely not a super complex or intense fantasy, so I think it works best if you go in expecting something simple and cozy rather than super detailed.
Overall, I felt like this was a sweet, easy, and comforting read. It didn’t completely blow me away, but I still enjoyed the experience and the cozy, witchy atmosphere it created. It’s a good pick if you’re in the mood for something light and relaxing.
Now for the star ratings I’m giving this book.
I’m giving this book an overall rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars.
The story is getting a rating of 4 out of 5 stars.
The writing style is getting a rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars.
The spicy level is getting a rating of 3 out of 5 stars.
The spicy rating would be a 3 or 4 according to romance.io stem rating guide. I’m taking a guess on what the rating would be as this book is not out yet.